Is YOYO just price gouging in disguise?

Margins make sellers do strange things.

Some polish titles, some squeeze keywords, and some… let’s just say creativity doesn’t always look good on the balance sheet.

The real question is—when does a hack actually help, and when does it hurt?

• Is YOYO a margin hack or a seller trap? ⚡
• Thought of the Day 🍴 
• Get Looped In and take the chaos out of ecommerce accounting ✉️
• We’ll link your newsletter for FREE. Send your applications here. 🤝

SELLERBITES INBOX

An Amazon seller (OP) asked: Is the YOYO repricing strategy actually effective?

In case you don’t know, YOYO stands for the “You’re On, You’re Off” repricing strategy. Sellers using this method will:

• Deliberately raise their price above the Buy Box for a short period—in OP’s case, every 3 hours for about 20 minutes.
• During this time, they’re “off” the Buy Box, letting competitors’ stock move.
• If inventory sells down, the market price can reset higher.
• They then lower their price to regain the Buy Box, ideally at a better margin.

The OP, a wholesale seller, wondered if this move could sneak in extra margin without wrecking sales velocity. They’d even heard whispers of sellers maxing prices overnight to squeeze out an annual boost. ⚖️

The responses showed just how split sellers are on the idea.

🎙️ Sellers spill their playbooks

Those in favor said YOYO can work—if you’re selective:

• Adds 2–5% margin annually on the right SKUs.
• Best on stable listings with predictable competitors.
• Falls apart when one aggressive repricer ignores the “game,” making you invisible for 20 minutes at a time.

Those against it argued it’s more risk than reward:

• Looks like price gouging, even if unintentional.
• Higher prices can spike returns and frustrate customers.
• Only effective if every reseller on the listing resets together—otherwise, repricers just push the floor back down.

And here’s the kicker: this isn’t just about margins, it’s about perception. Apple could never “YOYO” without backlash. But a gas station near an airport? Customers won’t even notice. 💡

The difference is whether you’re building a loyal customer base, or just flipping interchangeable widgets.

⚖️ The catch

YOYO isn’t a one-size-fits-all strategy. It can be a clever margin bump for wholesale resellers flipping generic SKUs—but it’s a brand liability for anyone building long-term customer loyalty. 

Many sellers agreed a broader dynamic pricing strategy is safer, more consistent, and less likely to backfire.

THOUGHT OF THE DAY

Pricing isn’t just about math—it’s about your business identity. Are you building a loyal brand or just chasing Buy Box scraps?

BITES OF THE WEEK

• Summit in Austin: A gathering of Austin's top ecommerce experts and decision-makers is coming this September 4.
• PPC Challenge: It's back! The 5-day Challenge will teach you proven Amazon PPC frameworks for only $77.
• Buy Box 2025: Want to win the Buy Box this 2025? Download this cheat sheet.
• ASGTG WhatsApp: If you're attending Amazon Accelerate, you should network with fellow sellers via ASGTG's WhatsApp.