Thinking it’s just another day… then a hijacker pops up with, “I’ll turn your listing into a dog.”
Probably nothing, right?
Suddenly, $20K, your Buy Box, and reviews are all at stake.
- Claim 15% off your smarter PPC 💸
- Threatened. Intimidated. $20K gone 😨
- Thought of the Day 🍴
SELLER CONFESSIONS
An Amazon seller (OP) confessed: They thought they were dealing with a harmless hijacker, until the seller threatened to burn the listing down and actually followed through.
OP spotted a new seller on the listing with a sketchy name and zero credibility. At first, it felt like a nuisance. Turns out, it was a slow-motion disaster that cost OP roughly $20,000.
⚠️ The warning signs sellers often miss
To experienced sellers, this setup looks familiar. Unfortunately, by the time OP clocked it, the damage was already in motion.
- Gibberish seller identity. A random, nonsense seller name with zero brand legitimacy.
- No trust signals. 0% lifetime rating and just two reviews, both negative.
- Phantom fulfillment. Orders were being taken, but nothing was actually shipping.
OP dug deeper to confirm what was going on. That’s when the hijacker dropped the mask, and the threat.
🧨 The threat that broke the listing
After placing a test order, OP received a message clearly meant to intimidate.
- Direct intimidation. The hijacker threatened to report OP for unfair competition.
- Scorched-earth intent. They warned they would “turn the listing into a dog.”
- System abuse. The entire threat leaned on Amazon’s slow enforcement cycle.
The worst part? OP didn’t realize the Buy Box had been lost for almost eight hours. By the time it was noticed, the bleeding had already started.
📉 How the damage snowballed
Over the next three months, everything unraveled.
- Sales collapse. Monthly volume dropped from ~500 units to fewer than 10.
Ranking freefall. Page one to effectively invisible. - Review poisoning. Buyers left negative reviews after never receiving products.
- Inventory lock-up. Legit stock became nearly impossible to move.
OP estimates the total hit at around $20,000, and that’s being conservative.
🛑 Amazon’s response: none
Multiple cases were filed. Brand Registry access was in place. Enforcement never showed up.
Commenters weren’t shocked. In categories with easy-to-replicate products, hijackers often move faster than Amazon can react. Those first few hours matter most, and that’s exactly where sellers are left exposed.
TOGETHER WITH REDHENLABS
Why Simpler Amazon PPC System Often Perform Better
Amazon’s ad ecosystem quietly rewards two things: control and efficiency.
Not flashy tactics. Not constant bid movement. Just consistent inputs into a system that already has enough volatility built in.
Attribution is delayed. Traffic quality fluctuates. Auction logic adjusts continuously in the background. In that environment, overly complex automation often ends up optimizing against incomplete data. Dayparting, hyper-granular rules, and aggressive AI reactions tend to create churn, not stability.
Experienced sellers usually arrive at the same conclusion the hard way: restraint performs better.
Strong Amazon PPC results typically come from:
- Simple automations that handle obvious, repeatable actions without thrashing
- Clean, readable campaign data that highlights what matters instead of burying it
When changes are deliberate and explainable, campaigns stay predictable. When reporting is clear, sellers spend less time decoding dashboards and more time making decisions Amazon’s system can actually reward.
RRW Ads was built around this reality. Automations are intentionally limited. AI recommendations explain their reasoning. Nothing goes live without approval. The goal isn’t to outsmart Amazon — it’s to operate efficiently inside it.
For SellerBites readers who already understand this dynamic:
Use promo code Adspend for 15% off your first three months.
THOUGHT OF THE DAY
Hijackers strike instantly. Amazon waits. Miss a Buy Box loss by hours, and your ranking, reviews, and momentum can disappear before anyone intervenes.
BITES OF THE WEEK
- February 9–11: Three-day Las Vegas summit uniting global supply chain leaders, logistics innovators, startups, and investors.
- February 13: Live EMARKETER summit explores creator commerce growth, shoppable video, livestreaming, and CTV strategies shaping 2026.
- February 19: Expert-led session on mastering visibility, content consistency, and pricing signals to stay AI-discoverable in 2026.
- February 24: EMARKETER hosts California events spotlighting commerce media and AI trends with analyst talks and networking.
